Tooling handled end to end · 5,000 pcs min · 20-minute quotes

Send artwork
AnvilPins Custom pins & cast metal goods

Guide

Soft enamel vs hard enamel: what actually differs

The three ways an enamel pin gets its colour, what each one feels like in the hand, and how the choice changes your artwork.

SOFT HARD colour below rim ground flush
Edge, section view · soft: enamel recessed · hard: polished flat

Three ways a pin gets its colour

Almost every enamel pin on a jacket is made one of three ways, and the difference is not cosmetic — it decides how the surface feels, how many colours you can use, and what the pin looks like after two years in a drawer.

Soft enamel (what we make)

A die is cut, the pin is cast in zinc alloy, and colour is filled into the recessed areas and left slightly below the metal ridge. Run a finger across it and you feel the ridges; the colour sits in the valleys. This is the process behind almost every event, school and club pin you have handled.

It allows a lot of colours at no extra tooling cost, holds fine detail, and costs less than the alternatives. What it does not give you is a perfectly flat surface.

Hard enamel

Same casting, different finishing: colour is filled and then the whole face is polished down flush with the metal, so the surface is smooth and the ridges disappear. The result is flatter, more jewellery-like, and more expensive, because polishing is a separate operation and colours are usually filled in several passes.

Hard enamel also constrains artwork more than soft: fine lines fill in during polishing, and very light colours can shift against the metal.

Printed (offset) pins

Instead of filling recesses, the design is printed directly onto a flat metal blank, often with an epoxy dome over the top. This is the only route that handles photographs and gradients. It is also the route where the image can fade or scratch, because the colour sits on the surface rather than in the metal.

Side by side

Aspect Soft enamel Hard enamel Printed
Surface Ridged, colour in the recess Flat, polished flush Flat, usually domed
Colours Many, no tooling penalty Many, but polishing constrains fine art Full photographic
Detail Fine lines hold well Fine lines can fill in Gradients yes, metal edges no
Durability Colour protected by the ridge Colour protected, surface can scratch Colour sits on top
Feel Textured Smooth Smooth, domed
Tooling Die plus colour fill Die plus fill and polish Die plus print

Which one to pick

Soft enamel is the right answer for most orders: school and club badges, event pins, staff recognition, brand merchandise, anything with a crest, strong line art or a lot of colour. It is the cheapest per piece at the same quantity, and the ridges read as “enamel pin” to anyone who has collected one.

Hard enamel makes sense when the pin is sold as a retail product and the surface has to feel premium in the hand — a museum shop, a fashion label, a limited edition. It costs more and needs simpler artwork.

Printed is the only choice for photographic artwork, and the sensible one for very large flat images where the metal outline is not the point.

What this means for your artwork

The good news is that the artwork requirements are almost identical across the three. Send vector artwork (AI, PDF or EPS) at finished size, with a Pantone reference or a physical sample for each colour. What changes is the minimum line weight: soft enamel holds a thinner line than hard, because nothing is polished away afterwards.

If you are unsure which process your design needs, send it and we will tell you — including when the answer is that a different process would serve the design better.

Where we fit

Our production is die-cast zinc alloy with colour filled into the recess, on flat or half-relief dies. That is the soft enamel route, and it is what the 5,000-piece minimum, the RMB 700 flat die and the 25-day lead time on this site all refer to. If a project needs a polished hard-enamel finish or a printed face, say so in the enquiry and we will quote it honestly rather than quietly switching the process.

Keep going

Send your drawing, get a price the same day

Artwork, size, quantity and deadline are all we need. A specialist replies with tooling cost, unit price and a delivery date, usually inside 20 minutes.

Request a quote